Type: Felony
Case no.: 15483 year 2010 Sidi Gaber registered no. 1216 year 2010 inclusive East Alexandria
Case year: 2010
Adverse: Public Prosecution
Representation: Accusation authority
First Verdict
Date: 26-10-2011
Judges: President – Moussa Ahmed Khalil Al Nahrawi
Members – Sobhi Abdo Youssef and Amr Abdul Salam Abbas
Court: Alexandria Criminal Court
Department: 14 Penal
No. of Defendants: 2
| S | Names | Verdict | Crime | Attending – in absentia |
| 1. | Mahmoud Salah Mahmoud Ghazala (police secretary) | Aggravated imprisonment for 7 years | 1- as a public employee he arrested a person without a legal right 2- used cruelty by physical torturing depending on his job | Attending |
| 2. | Awad Ismail Soleiman Abdul Maguid (police sergeant) | Aggravated imprisonment for 7 years | 1- as a public employee he arrested a person without a legal right 2- used cruelty by physical torturing depending on his job | Attending |
Verdict Text:
The court ruled in the attendance of the defendants to punish both of them with aggravated imprisonment for 7 years and obliged them to pay criminal expenses and the referral of the civil suit to the competent civil court and delayed the appreciation of the expenses
======================
First Cassation verdict
Date: 20-12-2012
Judges: President – Mohamed Adel Al Shorbagui
Members – Reda al Qadi – Abo Bakr Al Bassyouni – Ahmed Mostafa – Ahmed Hafiz – Nabil Al Keshki – Hossam Khalil – Hesham Abo Alam – Khaled Al Qdabi – Alaa Samhan and Mohamed Abdo Saleh
Court: Cassation
Department: non accessible
Defendants: 2
| S | Names | Verdict | Crime | Attending – in absentia |
| 1. | Mahmoud Salah Mahmoud Ghazala (police secretary) | Acceptance and repeat | 1- as a public employee he arrested a person without a legal right 2- used cruelty by physical torturing depending on his job | Attending |
| 2. | Awad Ismail Soleiman Abdul Maguid (police sergeant) | Acceptance and repeat | 1- as a public employee he arrested a person without a legal right 2- used cruelty by physical torturing depending on his job | Attending |
Verdict Text:
to accept the appeal in form and in subject to revoke the appealed verdict and the referral of the case to the Alexandria Criminal Court to repeat the trial in another department
===============================
Repeating trial verdict
Date: 3-3-2014
Judges: President – Awad Khalifa
Members – Mamdouh Abdul Dayem and Mostafa Rashad
Court: Alexandria Criminal Court
Department: 19
Defendants: 2
| S | Names | Verdict | Crime | Attending – in absentia |
| 1. | Mahmoud Salah Mahmoud Ghazala (police secretary) | Aggravated imprisonment for 10 years | 1- as a public employee he arrested a person without a legal right 2- used cruelty by physical torturing depending on his job | Attending |
| 2. | Awad Ismail Soleiman Abdul Maguid (police sergeant) | Aggravated imprisonment for 10 years | 1- as a public employee he arrested a person without a legal right 2- used cruelty by physical torturing depending on his job | Attending |
Verdict Text:
The court ruled in attendance of the two defendants to punish them of aggravated imprisonment for 10 years and obliged them to pay the criminal expenses
=============================
Second Cassation
Date: 4-3-2015
Judges: President – Magdi Abo Al Ela
Court: Cassation
Department: (A)
Defendants: 2
| S | Names | Verdict | Crime | Attending – in absentia |
| 1. | Mahmoud Salah Mahmoud Ghazala (police secretary) | Acceptance and support | 1- as a public employee he arrested a person without a legal right 2- used cruelty by physical torturing depending on his job | Attending |
| 2. | Awad Ismail Soleiman Abdul Maguid (police sergeant) | Acceptance and support | 1- as a public employee he arrested a person without a legal right 2- used cruelty by physical torturing depending on his job | Attending |
Verdict Text:
The court ruled to accept the appeal in form and reject it in subject and support the verdict issued against them
