Pulic Title for the case: Appealing against the Justice Minister’s decision no. 4991 year 2012 to grant military forces a judiciary

Type: Administrative cancellation and other administrative claims

Case no.: 46266 judiciary year 66 – 46269 judiciary year 66 – 46272 judiciary year 66 – 46282 judiciary year 66 – 46337 judiciary year 66 – 46435 judiciary year 66 – 46447 judiciary year 66 – 46503 judiciary year 66 – 46509 judiciary year 66 – 46510 judiciary year 66 – 46554 judiciary year 66 –

Date: 2012

Court: Administrative judiciary

Decision appealed against: Justice Minister’s decision no. 4991 year 2012

 

First verdict date:

Appellant: Mohamed Hamed Salem Al Sayed in case no 46266 judiciary year 66 – Nasser Mohamed Amin in case no. 46269 judiciary year 66 – Shehata Mohamed Shehata in case no. 46272 judiciary year 66 – Khaled Ali Omar, Hossam Bahgat, Bahi al Din Hassan, Ahmed Seif Al Islam Abdul Fattah, Nadim Abdullah Mansour in case 46282 judiciary year 66 – Abdel Monem Abdul Maqsoud Metwalli, Mohamed Said Tosson, Mohamed al Mati, Kamel Mandour, Nasser Salem Hafi, Sayed Hussein Gadallah, Ossama al Helw, Gamal al Din Tag al Din Hassan, Ali Gamal, Hatem Abdul Wahab, Gamal Hanafi Gamal, Mokhtar Al Ashri, Mohamed Ali al Sayed, Bassam Erian, Hassan Saleh Ahmed, Mostafa al Demeiri, Ezzat Eid Ghoneim 46337 judiciary year 66 – Hamed Sediq Sayed Mekki 46435 judiciary year 66 – Mohamed Said Mohamed Abdul Rehim 46447 judiciary year 66 – Taher Atia Abu al Nasr, Maha Mahmoud  Youssef, Rawda Ahmed Sayed 46503 judiciary year 66 – Adel Mohamed Sharaf al Din 46509 judiciary year 66 – Mohamed Abdul Aal Mohamed 46510 judiciary year 66 – Essam Omar Mohamed Qandil 46554

judiciary year 66

The Appealed against: Minister of Justice in cases no. 46266 judiciary year 66 – 46269 judiciary year 66 – 46272 judiciary year 66 – – 46509 judiciary year 66 – 46510 judiciary year 66 – 46554 judiciary year 66 –  (Head of the Supreme Council of the Armed forces – Minister of Justice – Defense Minister – Public Prosecutor – Head of the Military Justice – Military Public Attorney) 46282 judiciary year 66 – 46337 judiciary year 66 – (Minister of Justice – Defense Minister) 46435 judiciary year 66 – (Head of the Supreme Council of the Armed forces –  Minister of Justice – Prime Minister) 46447 judiciary year 66 – (Head of the Supreme Council of the Armed forces – Minister

of Justice) 46503 judiciary year 66

Judges: President – Ali Fekri Hassan Saleh

Members: Abdul Salam Abdul Maguid al Naggar and Sami Ramadan Mohamed Darwish

Verdict text: The court ruled of the acceptance of the lawsuit in form and to suspend the Minister of Justice’s decision no. 4991 year 2012 with what results from this and obliged the administrative body to pay expenses and the referral of the lawsuit to the State Commissioners Authority to prepare a report concerning the legal point of view.