Pulic Title for the case: Atef Mohamed Obeid (al Bayada island case) 11862 year 2011 al Doqi Department

Type: Felony

Case no.: 11862 year 2011 al Doqi Department registered no. 1160 year 2011

Case year: from 2000 to 2006

Adverse: Public Prosecutor

Representation: Accusation authority

Notes: Trial of one of the symbols of the ousted regime Hosni Mubarak

First Verdict

Date: 1-3-2012

Judges: President – Mohamed Fahim Darwish

Court: Al Giza Criminal Court

Department: non accessible

No. of Defendants: 7

Accusations: Defendants from the first to the fifth:

1- exploiting his job as public employee to facilitate to rob others in intention to possess lands owned by a public body

2- exploiting his job as a public employee to facilitate profit and interest acquisition for others

3- damaging public finance and interests for public bodies as a public employee

Third defendant: attempt to acquire interest without a right through a task of his public job in service of the second defendant

Sixth and Seventh defendant: participating with the first to the fifth defendants through agreement and assistance in a the crime mentioned in the accusations of the first and second for the five defendants

 

S Name Verdict Attending – in absentia
     1. Atef Mohamed Mohamed Obaid

 

Ten Fifteen  years aggravated imprisonment Attending
     2. Yousef Amin Wali

 

Ten Fifteen  years aggravated imprisonment Attending
     3. Ahmed Abdel Fattah Sayed Ahmed Fifteen years imprisonment In absentia
     4.  

Mahmoud Abdel Bar Salem

Acquittal Attending
     5. Said Abdel Fattah Abdel Latif Three years aggravated imprisonment Attending
     6.  Hussein Kamal Eddin Ibrahim Salem Fifteen  years aggravated imprisonment In absentia
     7. Khaled Hussein Kamal Eddin Ibrahim Salem Fifteen  years aggravated imprisonment In absentia

 

First Verdict Text:

The court ruled in attendance of  the following defendants: 1st, 2nd, 4th, and 5th and in absentia of the third, sixth and seventh the following

First: to  punish the first and second defendant with aggravated imprisonment for 10 years, and to punish the fifth with aggravated imprisonment for three years and to punish the third, sixth and seventh with imprisonment for 15 years

Second: to oblige them in solidarity to pay an amount of 769,086,349 L.E. and to fine them with an equal amount for the accusations attributed to them and to isolate them from their jobs for the first to the fifth except for the forth

Third: the acquittal of the fourth defendant

Fourth: the referral of the civil suit to a the compentent civil court wihtout expenses filed by the Minister of Agriculture

======================================

First Cassation Verdict

Date: 23-1-2013

Judges: President – Hamed Abdullh

Members – Yahya Khalifa and Mohamed Eid Salem and Mohmaed Mahmoud Mahamid and Mansour anl Qadi

Court: Cassation Court

Department: Wednesday (b)

  1. of defendants: 3

accusations:

1- exploiting his job as a public employee in facilitating for others to seize lands owned to a public body in intention to possess it

2- exploiting his job as a public employee to allow others to acquire profit and interest without a right

3- damaging finances and interests of public bodies as a public employee

 

S Names Verdict Attending – in absentia
1 Atef Mohamed Mohamed Ebeid Acceptance and retrial Attending
2 Youssef Amin Wali Acceptance and retrial Attending
3 Said Abdul Fattah Abdullatif Acceptance and retrial Attending

 

Verdict text:

The court ruled to accept the appeal filed by the appellants in form and in subject to suspend the verdict appealed against and repeat the case and refer it to Al Giza Criminal Court to consider it in a different

department

======================================

 

Retrial Verdict

Date: 9-2-2017

Judges: President – Gamal Abdulleh

Members – Abdulnasser abu Sehli and Essam al Doweini

Court: Al Giza Criminal Court

Department: 17

No. of defendants: 6

Accusations of the defendants from the first to the fourth:

 

1- exploiting his job as a public employee in facilitating for others to seize lands owned to a public body in intention to possess it

2- exploiting his job as a public employee to allow others to acquire profit and interest without a right

 

3- damaging finances and interests of public bodies as a public employee

 

Third defendant: attempting to acquire interest without a right through a task of his public job for the interest of  the second defendants

fifth and sixth defendants: participating with the first to the fifth defendants in the ways of agreement and assistance in the crime which the first and the second defendants are accused of for the five defendants

S Names Verdict Attending – in absentia
1. Atef Mohamed Mohamed Obaid

 

Deceased Attending
2. Yousef Amin Wali

 

Reconciliation Attending
3. Ahmed Abdel Fattah Sayed Ahmed Reconciliation Attending
4.  

Mahmoud Abdel Bar Salem

Reconciliation Attending
5. Said Abdel Fattah Abdel Latif Reconciliation Attending
6.  Hussein Kamal Eddin Ibrahim Salem Reconciliation Attending

 

Verdict:

The court ruled of:

First: the termination of the case for the death of the first defendants

Second: the termination of the case for the reconciliation