Pulic Title for the case: Al Etehadia Palace incidents (year 2013 Masr Al Gadida crimes registered no. 936 year 2013 inclusive East Cairo)

Type: Felony

Case no.: year 2013 Masr Al Gadida crimes registered no. 936 year 2013 inclusive East Cairo

Case year: 2013

Adverse: Public Prosecution

Representation: Accusation Authority

First Verdict:

Date: 21st April 2015

Judges: President – Ahmed Sabri Youssef

Members  – Ahmed Abu Al Fotouh and Hussein Qandil

Court: Cairo Criminal Court

Defendants: 15

 

Serial no. Name Verdict State Crime
(1) Assad Mohamed Ahmed Al Sheikha
  • Aggravated imprisonment for 20 years
  • subjecting the defendant for 5 years under the surveillance of the police
  • acquittal
Attending
  • Demonstration of force and waving of violence
  • Murder
  • The detention of others without the order of one of the competent authorities coupled with physical torture
  • Possession of a firearm or ammunition without a license
(2) Ahmed Mohamed Mohamed Abdul Aati
  • Aggravated imprisonment for 20 years
  • subjecting the defendant for 5 years under the surveillance of the police
  • acquittal
Attending
  • Demonstration of force and waving of violence
  • Murder
  • The detention of others without the order of one of the competent authorities coupled with physical torture
  • Possession of a firearm or ammunition without a license
(3)  

Ayman Abdul Raouf Ali Ahmed Hodhod

  • Aggravated imprisonment for 20 years
  • subjecting the defendant for 5 years under the surveillance of the police
  • acquittal
Attending
  • Demonstration of force and waving of violence
  • Murder
  • The detention of others without the order of one of the competent authorities coupled with physical torture
  • Possession of a firearm or ammunition without a license
(4) Alaa Hamza Ali AL Sayed
  • Aggravated imprisonment for 20 years
  • subjecting the defendant for 5 years under the surveillance of the police
  • acquittal
Attending
  • Demonstration of force and waving of violence
  • Murder
  • The detention of others without the order of one of the competent authorities coupled with physical torture
  • Possession of a firearm or ammunition without a license
(5) Reda Mohamed AL Sawi Mohamed
  • Aggravated imprisonment for 20 years
  • subjecting the defendant for 5 years under the surveillance of the police
  • acquittal
In absentia
  • Demonstration of force and waving of violence
  • Murder
  • The detention of others without the order of one of the competent authorities coupled with physical torture
  • Possession of a firearm or ammunition without a license
(6) LamLoum Mekkawi Gomaa Afifi
  • Aggravated imprisonment for 20 years
  • subjecting the defendant for 5 years under the surveillance of the police
  • acquittal
In absentia
  • Demonstration of force and waving of violence
  • Murder
  • The detention of others without the order of one of the competent authorities coupled with physical torture
  • Possession of a firearm or ammunition without a license
(7) Abdul Hakim Ismail Abdul Rahman
  • Aggravated imprisonment for 10 years
  • subjecting the defendant for 5 years under the surveillance of the police
  • acquittal
Attending
  • Demonstration of force and waving of violence
  • Murder
  • The detention of others without the order of one of the competent authorities coupled with physical torture
  • Possession of a firearm or ammunition without a license
 (8) Hani Sayed Tawfiq Sayed
  • Aggravated imprisonment for 20 years
  • subjecting the defendant for 5 years under the surveillance of the police
  • acquittal
In absentia
  • Demonstration of force and waving of violence
  • Murder
  • The detention of others without the order of one of the competent authorities coupled with physical torture
  • Possession of a firearm or ammunition without a license
 (9) Ahmed Mostafa Hussein Mohamed al Moghir
  • Aggravated imprisonment for 20 years
  • subjecting the defendant for 5 years under the surveillance of the police
  • acquittal
In absentia
  • Demonstration of force and waving of violence
  • Murder
  • The detention of others without the order of one of the competent authorities coupled with physical torture
  • Possession of a firearm or ammunition without a license
 (10) Abdul Rahman Ezz Al Din Imam
  • Aggravated imprisonment for 20 years
  • subjecting the defendant for 5 years under the surveillance of the police
  • acquittal
In absentia
  • Demonstration of force and waving of violence
  • Murder
  • The detention of others without the order of one of the competent authorities coupled with physical torture
  • Possession of a firearm or ammunition without a license
(11) Gamal Saber Mohamed Mostafa
  • Aggravated imprisonment for 10 years
  • subjecting the defendant for 5 years under the surveillance of the police
  • acquittal
Attending
  • Demonstration of force and waving of violence
  • Murder
  • The detention of others without the order of one of the competent authorities coupled with physical torture
  • Possession of a firearm or ammunition without a license
(12) Mohamed Mohamed Morsi Eissa al Ayat
  • Aggravated imprisonment for 20 years
  • subjecting the defendant for 5 years under the surveillance of the police
  • acquittal
Attending
  • Participate in methods of incitement, agreement and assistance in committing murder, parading force, detaining and torturing others
(13) Mohamed Mohmed Ibrahim Al Beltagi
  • Aggravated imprisonment for 20 years
  • subjecting the defendant for 5 years under the surveillance of the police
  • acquittal
Attending
  • Participate in methods of incitement, agreement and assistance in committing murder, parading force, detaining and torturing others
(14) Essam Al Din Mohamed Hassan Al Erian
  • Aggravated imprisonment for 20 years
  • subjecting the defendant for 5 years under the surveillance of the police
  • acquittal
Attending
  • Participate in methods of incitement, agreement and assistance in committing murder, parading force, detaining and torturing others
(15) Wagdi Abdul Hamid Ghoneim
  • Aggravated imprisonment for 20 years
  • subjecting the defendant for 5 years under the surveillance of the police
  • acquittal
In absentia
  • Participate in methods of incitement, agreement and assistance in committing murder, parading force, detaining and torturing others

 

Verdict Text:

The court ruled in the attendance of the first, second, third, fourth, seventh, 11th, 12th, 13th and 14th and in absentia of the rest

First: the rejection of the defense of the non competence of the court to consider the lawsuit, and to punish all defendants except the seventh and the eleventh with aggravated imprisonment for twenty years and to subject them to police surveillance for five years for the two accusations: parading force and detention without the order of the competent governor joined with physical torture. And to punish the seventh and the eleventh with aggravated imprisonment for ten years and to be subjected to police surveillance for five years for the two accusations: parading force and the detention of others without the order of the competent governor joined with physical torture, the court ruled of the acquittal of all defendants from the accusations of murder and acquisition of firearms and ammunitions without a license and obliged all defendants to pay the expenses